What critics and viewers don’t like
Despite big names and high production value, The Abandons is often described as “shallow” and “over-blown.” Reviewers say its plot is clichéd, its dialogue feels forced, and many characters come off as one-dimensional.
Many feel that the show tries too hard — borrowing heavily from well-known Western tropes — but fails to deliver originality. The writing is called derivative and heavily reliant on formulaic conflicts, which makes even dramatic moments feel predictable.
The pacing and tone have also drawn criticism: scenes jump quickly, character motivations and world-building are often underdeveloped, and the series is described as emotionally hollow — viewers struggle to feel invested in the conflict.